Executive Director Notes

State has a long way to go to curb global warming

As the long, dark nights of winter stretch out before us, it is a good time to reflect on how the electricity that we need to illuminate our lives is generated and the impact that that has on global warming. 

Some would paint a rosy picture of Wisconsin's contribution to eliminating greenhouse gasses. Brett Hulsey’s recent opinion piece correctly cited laudable strides made in ethanol production, converting methane to power, and moves by UW campuses to "lead by example and go off the grid" – all initiatives for which we applaud Governor Doyle’s leadership. However, Hulsey failed to note that the real elephant on the table in terms of emitting global warming gasses - and therefore the sector where efforts can and should be focused - is coal-fired power plants. 

By far the largest contributor to global warming emissions in the state, the existing coal-fired power plants alone currently emit 47 million tons of carbon dioxide and other global warming gasses each and every year.  Add to this the fact that more new coal-fired power plants are on the drawing boards, and the number goes up to almost 60 million tons of global warming gasses that Wisconsin's power industry will belch annually up into the atmosphere.  Other contributors to global warming gasses - agriculture, for example - pale in comparison, so it is the power companies that deserve the attention not accorded them.  

Utilities and the coal industry are marketing coal fired electricity generation as a necessary resource to meet future energy needs.  However, continued reliance on coal as a fuel for electricity production is dangerous and irresponsible.  In fact, Wisconsin's own State Energy Priorities Law lists coal-fired power generation dead last. 

Surely the state of Wisconsin can do better than dusting off the nine-year-old Wisconsin Climate Change Action Plan - as Mr. Hulsey did - to make significant strides toward curbing global warming.  Using a study whose most recent data is six years old begs the question of how closely we are paying attention to the impact that this crucial issue is having on the landscape right here in Wisconsin. Other states - including California and New Mexico have recognized the importance of addressing this problem and have taken it head on. Closer to home, the states of Illinois and Minnesota have formed a Global Warming Advisory Council and called for a 15% reduction in fossil fuels by 2015, respectively. Wisconsin can – and should – follow suit.

Given Wisconsin's traditions of innovation and "can-do" attitude, it is surprising that not a single electric power utility has fully embraced cleaner, more efficient power-generating technologies that minimize or eliminate greenhouse gasses.  Wisconsin deserves the best in clean, responsible energy choices that meet our needs for electricity, but also protect our environment. 

It's time to stop building dirty, outdated coal plants.  Then watch Wisconsin make progress on global warming.

Mark Redsten
Executive Director
Clean Wisconsin